Powers of Attorney

Who Is Involved?

Can I Appoint A Successor Agent?

You can appoint a successor agent to replace an agent under a Power of Attorney

· 11 min read

What Does The Term “Successor Agent” Mean?

A successor agent is a replacement for an original agent who is ineligible.

Do Different States Use Different Terminology?

The term successor agent is the term used in the legislation of all of the Six (6) Greater States, except California, to identify a replacement for an original agent.

For this reason, the term successor agent is preferred in this Wiki.

California legislation uses the term alternate agent (§4014).

Legislative links: New York §5-1501, Illinois §2-10.3, Pennsylvania §5602(b) Florida §709.2102 Texas §751.023).

When Does A Successor Agent Replace An Original Agent?

The legislation of the Six (6) Greater States governing certain Powers of Attorney for persons1is inconsistent with respect to when a successor agent takes office:

silentin California, legislation is silent as to whether a successor agent might replace an agent before every agent is ineligible.
only replace when all ineligiblein Texas a successor agent is not considered an agent and may not act until all predecessor agents, including co-agents, to the successor agent have resigned, died, or become incapacitated, are not qualified to serve, or have declined to serve (see §751.023).
replace when any ineligiblein New York, a principal may designate one or more successor agents to serve, if any initial or predecessor agent resigns, dies, becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve or declines to serve” (see §5-1508).

Can An Already Nominated Agent Be A Successor Agent?

Nominating a person as a successor agent who is not otherwise identified as an agent under the Power of Attorney (i.e not an already designated agent) is common.

Less common, is the idea of appointing as a successor agent an already nominated agent.

In California, Texas and Florida recognition of this entitlement is stronger:

California Succession rules include that a principal may designate a successor agent to replace an agent (§4203) and the expression of this rule in §4203 includes the defined term attorney-in-fact to identify who may be replaced by a successor agent, attorney-in-fact being defined to include a person granted authority to act for the principal (§4010) which presumably, includes a successor agent.
TexasA principal may designate in a durable Power of Attorney one or more successor agents to act if an agent resigns, dies, or becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve, or declines to serve (§751.023) and the term agent is recognized in §751.002(3) to include an attorney in fact and a co-agent, successor agent, or successor co-agent.
FloridaPursuant to §709.2111 a principal may designate one or more successor agents to act if an agent resigns, dies, becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve, or declines to serve and §709.2102 defines an agent as a person granted authority to act for a principal under a power of attorney, whether denominated an agent, attorney in fact, or otherwise. The last word otherwise in §709.2102 seems to embrace any designated agent, so as to include any agent identified in the Power of Attorney which of course, would include a successor agent.

By contrast:

New York
Illinois

Similarly in Illinois and Pennsylvania, the legislation is not expressly clear.

  • §2-10.5 says a principal may provide for the appointment of one or more successor agents who shall serve in the order named in the Power Of Attorney, unless the principal expressly directs to the contrary.

  • this might leaves the position unclear, except that §2-4 makes clear a principal may specify in the agency the event or time when the agency will begin and terminate, the mode of revocation or amendment and the rights, powers, duties, limitations, immunities and other terms applicable to the agent and to all persons dealing with the agent, and the provisions of the agency will control notwithstanding this Act.

  • on its face, §2-4 leaves the door wide open, imposing no restriction upon a principal permitting a successor agent to replace a successor agent, if the principal adopts suitable terms in the Power of Attorney.

  • however where a Power of Attorney is silent upon this issue, §2-10.5 seems only to assist by recognizing it may be possible, perhaps concerningly making it less arguable if not improper, for a successor agent to replace another successor agent.

  • §2-4 might be construed as limiting the options available to the principal to what is expressly specified in the Power of Attorney.

  • good arguments against this approach including that presumably, all of the rules dealing with duties, limitations, immunities and other terms applicable to the agent and to all persons dealing with the agent could not possibly be perceived as capable of being recorded in a Power of Attorney and so, if those components of §2-4 are to be read as informed by their common law background, presumably something not as much as expressly mentioned in §2-4 would also be assumed, where the common law presumably, accommodates all designs of Powers of Attorney - i.e including designs where a successor agent replaces another successor agent.

Pennsylvania
  • §5602 says A principal may provide for the appointment of one or more successor agents who shall serve in the order named in the power of attorney, unless the principal expressly directs to the contrary.

  • these are the same as the words in §2-10.5 in Illinois.

  • in Pennsylvania, §5602 says a principal may provide for the “the delegation to an original or successor agent of the power to appoint his successor or successors” leaving no doubt as to whether a successor agent can be replaced (which falls short of expressly confirming that any replacement for a successor agent may be a successor agent).

  • there is no provision in Pennsylvania which is equivalent to §2-4 in Illinois.

  • this seems of little significance, given the purpose of §2-4 in Illinois (in the relevant sense) seems to be to only reinforce the position at common law, at least other than to the extent that §2-4 speaks of regulating immunities and inclusion of terms applicable to persons dealing with the agent and these words takes things further, if at all.

Can You Appoint A Protector To Choose Successor Agents On Your Behalf?

A successor agent may be nominated by name in all of the Six (6) Greater States.

In four of the Six (6) Greater States (California, Texas, Illinois and Pennsylvania) a person may also be nominated as a successor agent by someone other than the principal, after the Power of Attorney is made, as opposed to necessarily being named in the Power of Attorney:

  • in Pennsylvania, §5602 says that a principal may provide for the the delegation to an original or successor agent of the power to appoint his successor or successors i.e. an agent or successor agent may be authorized under a Power of Attorney to appoint their own successor agent.
  • in California, Texas and Illinois, a protector identified by office, function or title may be authorized to “designate” successor agents.

Legislative links: California §4203, Illinois §2-10.3 & Texas (only in respect of a durable Power of Attorney) §751.023.

Quick Summary

Below are various key observations with respect to regulated Powers of Attorney, in relation to identification of successor agents in the Six (6) Greater States.

California

§4203 provides:-

a principal may designate one or more successor attorneys-in-fact to act if the authority of a predecessor attorney-in-fact terminates..

Texas

In respect of a durable Power of Attorney, a successor agent may act if an agent resigns, dies, or becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve, or declines to serve (see §751.023).

Unless a Power of Attorney provides otherwise, a successor is not considered an agent and may not act until all predecessor agents, including co-agents, to the successor agent have resigned, died, or become incapacitated, are not qualified to serve, or have declined to serve (see §751.023).

This means for example, that unless a Power of Attorney says otherwise, a designated successor agent is not considered to be a successor agent, until they replace an agent who but for their ineligibility, would be an agent under the Power of Attorney.

This may or may not be how the principal would prefer things to work.

A principal might prefer that a successor agent actually be recognized as an agent under their Power of Attorney, despite having no role to play per se (in terms of performing tasks etc.) until the office of an agent being an agent they are eligible to replace, is vacant and they actually replace them.

No doubt not every principal may prefer things work this way, however some might.

In Texas, care might be taken to confirm whether or not a principal is content for their Power of Attorney to work such that a designated successor agent is not considered to be a successor agent, until or unless they replace an agent who otherwise would be an agent under the Power of Attorney, but for their ineligibility.

New York

If two agents are appointed to act together, a Power of Attorney takes effect only when all agents have accepted appointment (§5-1508 ).

A closer examination of §5-1508 shows that in §5-1508(1) states [u]nless the principal provides otherwise in the power of attorney, the co-agents must act jointly.

speaks of a

§5-1508 does not provide that §5-1508 is subject to any contrary terms contained in the Power of Attorney (i.e. any words to the contrary, of the principal's choice).

This kind of ‘restriction’ is not seen in any of the Six (6) Greater States.

  • albeit it also said to be unless the Power of Attorney provides otherwise, in §5-1508 it is said that if a vacancy occurs because of the death, resignation or incapacity of a co-agent, the remaining agent or agents may act for the principal" and “a principal may designate one or more successor agents to serve, if any initial or predecessor agent resigns, dies, becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve or declines to serve which at least one reasonable reading, is quite different from how things work in Texas for example in respect of a durable Power of Attorney, at least unless the Power of Attorney says otherwise.
  • It seems in New York whilst a principal may provide for specific succession rules (§5-1508) absent any express provision in a Power of Attorney, a successor agent seems to be entitled to replace an agent well before all agents have become ineligible, unlike Texas where absent any express provision in a durable Power of Attorney, the position is opposite

Florida

Pursuant to §709.2111, a principal may designate two or more persons to act as co-agents and a principal may designate one or more successor agents to act if an agent resigns, dies, becomes incapacitated, is not qualified to serve, or declines to serve and a successor agent may not act until the predecessor agents have resigned, have died, have become incapacitated, are no longer qualified to serve, or have declined to serve, which seems to align Florida to the New York approach as opposed to the Texas approach as referred to in the previous bullet paragraph, albeit equally said in Florida to work this way unless the Power of Attorney otherwise provides.

Illinois

§2-10.5 says a principal may provide for the appointment of one or more successor agents who shall serve in the order named in the Power Of Attorney, unless the principal expressly directs to the contrary which does not address whether a successor agent is entitled to replace an agent well before all agents have become ineligible, in the way California, New York and (in respect of a durable Power of Attorney) Texas have

leaves things slightly unclear in terms of whether these words refer to the ‘Texas’ approach or ‘Florida/New York’ approach explained above - that is, whether a successor agent is entitled to replace an agent well before all agents have become ineligible, which is one possible interpretation of these words.

Perhaps in Illinois the effect of these words includes preventing other arrangements being adopted given §2-10.5 says nothing to the effect “unless the Power of Attorney otherwise provides”, although views may differ because for example, §2-4 states “The principal may specify in the agency the event or time when the agency will begin and terminate, the mode of revocation or amendment and the rights, powers, duties, limitations, immunities and other terms applicable to the agent and to all persons dealing with the agent, and the provisions of the agency will control notwithstanding this Act”.

Pennsylvania

§5602 says “A principal may provide for the appointment of one or more successor agents who shall serve in the order named in the power of attorney, unless the principal expressly directs to the contrary” being words that similar to §2-10.5 in Illinois, seem to leave things unclear as to whether a successor agent is entitled to replace an agent well before all agents have become ineligible although it seems possible in Pennsylvania for a principal to specify how they want things to work in any event.

§5602 also says a principal may provide for the “the delegation to an original or successor agent of the power to appoint his successor or successors”, making it clear that there is no restriction upon a successor agent being succeeded by another successor agent, which might be questionable in other states.

  1. Being not a Power of Attorney excluded from the ambit of the legislation - click here to read more. ↩︎