Powers of Attorney

What Is The Law?

How Have Powers of Attorney Developed?

The history, reform and future of Powers of Attorney, in America and beyond.

· 12 min read

Do Powers of Attorney Feature In Ancient History?

Ancient Babylonian history provides the earliest records of arrangements of the kind achieved using a Power of Attorney.1

  • in 561 B.C., two brothers, Itti-Nabu-balatu and Bel-kishir, inherited or shared property from their father, Shula. Bel-kishir did not want to participate in certain day-to-day business and empowered his brother to take his share, invest it in the market and run the business on his behalf and deliver to Bel-kishir his share of profit; and
  • in 452 B.C., two brothers, Arad-Anu-ilu-la-ilu-iprus and Shapi, owned a house that generated 18 shekels of silver in rent. They appointed a third person to collect the rent on their behalf and apply it to the purposes they specified.

Are Powers of Attorney Seen In Early History?

The Latin maxim qui facit per alium, facit per se (he who acts through another, acts himself) has been part of the common law for centuries, capturing the conceptual essence of Powers of Attorney.

In 1785, George Washington, writing from Mount Vernon, granted a Power of Attorney to Battaile Muse, his rental agent, to collect the rents on his western lands, one of many Powers of Attorney he used to manage his financial and property affairs during periods of absence.2

Have Powers of Attorney Developed In Recent Years?

In 1954, Virginia enacted the first statute allowing a Power of Attorney to continue beyond the principal’s incapacity.[3]

In 1983, California was the first state in America to recognize a durable Power of Attorney for health care.

By 1979 the Uniform Durable Power of Attorney Act had been approved and began being enacted by various states.

In 1993, the Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act, the national code for Medical Powers of Attorney (revised in 2023), was released by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (“ULC”).

In 2006, the Uniform Power of Attorney Act, the current national code for Powers of Attorney, was released by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (“ULC”) and the Third Restatement of the Law of Agency was published by the American Law Institute.

The 2010 article Power of Attorney: Convenient Contract or Dangerous Document? by Catherine Seal is recommended further reading for anyone interested in gaining a better understanding of the common law background and legislative initiatives which have facilitated what is recognized today as the modern, durable Power of Attorney.

National uniformity is broadly recognized as a positive objective for America, however as this Wiki demonstrates, at a cellular level there are many differences in the laws of various states. Almost every issue addressed in this Wiki is not approached the same way by each of the Six (6) Greater States and for example, some US States have chosen not to adopt the national code at all. Of course, there are also Powers of Attorney that operate under federal law.3

For example:-

Have There Been Recent Developments In The Six (6) Greater States?

California

In 1983, California was the first state in America to recognize a durable Power of Attorney for health care.

In 1994, a California Law Revision Commission Report, led to the enactment of Division 4.5 of the Probate Code.

The following extract from the 1994 report explains the intended role of the current, Division 4.5 of the Probate Code at the time it was written:

“The new law… [will] replace the incomplete and disorganized collection of power of attorney statutes currently located with the other agency rules in the Civil Code…”

“The statutes governing powers of attorney are in need of reorganization and revision.[4] Since 1979, several bills have been enacted recognizing general durable powers of attorney and durable powers of attorney for health care, providing statutory forms, specifying a procedure for enforcement of the duties of attorneys-in-fact, and making a number of other changes in the law…”

“…the piecemeal nature of the revisions over the past 12 years has resulted in a disorganized set of statutes… unclear… obscure and incomplete… [providing] little practical guidance…”

“The proposed Power of Attorney Law restructures the Power of Attorney statutes and relocates them as a new Division 4.5 of the Probate Code, starting with Section 4000”.

The new Division 4.5 of the Probate Code is complimented by Division 4.7 of the Probate Code dealing with medical Powers of Attorney

California does not appear to have revisited its laws since 2006.

This 2009 publication by the Trusts & Estates Section of the State Bar of California is interesting.

Texas

Revisited its laws in 2018, passing further legislation acknowledged by the ULC as consistent with the ULC’s 2006 recommendations.

Interestingly and unusually (no equivalent having been introduced in any of the other of the Six (6) Greater States) in 2017, the legislature included §751.003 in the Texas Estates Code, directed to promoting uniformity amongst states, stating (in relation to Subtitle P governing durable Powers of Attorney):

This subtitle shall be applied and construed to effect the general purpose of this subtitle, which is to make uniform to the fullest extent possible the law with respect to the subject of this subtitle among states enacting these provisions.”

New YorkIn December 2020, New York passed new laws effective 13 June 2021 dealing with Powers of Attorney, being the most recent round of substantial amendments made in any of the Six (6) Greater States. These amendments defined changes including discontinuance of use of a statutory gifts rider, sanctions for third parties who refuse to accept a Power of Attorney and other variations (see Assembly Bill A5630 ).
FloridaRevisited its laws substantially in 2011, passing new legislation.
IllinoisRevisited its laws substantially in 2011, passing new legislation.
PennsylvaniaRevisited its laws substantially in 2014-2016, passing new legislation.

Has Illinois Recognized Having Powers of Attorney As A Human Right?

Powers of Attorney have a fundamental role in a human rights context.

The power to delegate tasks or functions to another legal entity is a legal right.

Article 29 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognizes the right of a person to exercise legal rights without limitation, other than where limitation is necessary to protect the freedoms of others or meet moral or public order objectives.

In Illinois, the importance of preserving freedom of choice in the context of Power of Attorney arrangements has been expressly recognized in its legislation:

The General Assembly recognizes that each individual has the right to appoint an agent to make property, financial, personal, and health care decisions for the individual but that this right cannot be fully effective unless the principal may empower the agent to act throughout the principal’s lifetime, including during periods of disability, and have confidence that third parties will honor the agent’s authority at all times…: See §2-1

The principal may specify in the agency the event or time when the agency will begin and terminate, the mode of revocation or amendment and the rights, powers, duties, limitations, immunities and other terms applicable to the agent and to all persons dealing with the agent, and the provisions of the agency will control notwithstanding this Act…: See §2-4

By contrast for example, California identifies requirements of its legislation that are unable to be varied (see §4101).

The words …the provisions of the agency will control notwithstanding this Act… adopted in Illinois and cited above seem intended to ensure that anyone creating a Power of Attorney is as free as possible, in deciding how to structure their Power of Attorney affairs, however they wish.

Is The National Perspective Fluid?

The law in all of the Six (6) Greater States relating to Powers of Attorney continues to be refined by Courts and legislation.

For example:-

  • In 2006, the most recent national code for Powers of Attorney was released by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (“ULC”) and the Third Restatement of the Law of Agency was published by the American Law Institute.
  • In December 2020 New York passed legislation that defines various changes to take effect on June 13, 2021 including discontinuance of use of a statutory gifts rider, sanctions for third parties who refuse to accept a Power of Attorney and other variations (A5630).

National uniformity remains a common objective across US States, with continuing initiatives for reform being managed at federal and state level.

As referred to in the table above, interestingly and unusually, in 2017 in Texas, §751.003 was enacted to promote uniformity amongst states, by providing with respect to Subtitle P which governs durable Powers of Attorney in Texas:

This subtitle shall be applied and construed to effect the general purpose of this subtitle, which is to make uniform to the fullest extent possible the law with respect to the subject of this subtitle among states enacting these provisions.

Are Powers of Attorney Evolving In A Global Context?

Interesting global developments in the last 15 years include, for example:-

In South Africa for example, the law is yet to recognize a durable Power of Attorney.

Where Do Powers of Attorney Sit In A Broader Perspective?

The law of agency is a cornerstone, in the context of identifying the law applicable to Powers of Attorney.

A technical analysis of the history and operation of Powers of Attorney would touch upon:-

  • empowering others to act on another's behalf (i.e. delegated authority)
  • powers coupled with an interest4 (distinguished from naked or bare authorities)
  • disposal of interests5 (distinguishing powers of appointment in contexts not involving the appointor's property, such as trust property, from Powers of Attorney which dispose of the appointor's property)
  • the effects of incapacity of the principal6 (i.e. development of the modern, durable Power of Attorney)

The law pertaining to Powers of Attorney is continually being refined and developed.

Change in the law can come about in a variety of ways.

For example:-

  • new legislation may be enacted to deal with something new (e.g. digital assets and cryptocurrency);
  • new legislation may be enacted to modify the common law (e.g. the legislation referred to above, permitting the creation of durable Powers of Attorney);
  • existing legislation may be amended or replaced (e.g. New York’s 2021 overhaul of its Power of Attorney provisions); and
  • the common law may be clarified or developed by the courts, which also settle what the legislation means.

When new legislation is enacted it modifies common law principles by either:-

  • abrogating them (i.e replacing a common law rule with a different statutory one);
  • codifying them (i,e restating a settled principle in statutory words without changing its effect); or
  • building on them (i.e adding to them, with new principles).

Broadly speaking, in the context of Powers of Attorney where legislation is silent the law of agency continues to apply, although there are also legal principles that are recognized as uniquely relevant to Powers of Attorney.

  1. See Fordham University, A Collection of Contracts from Mesopotamia, c. 2300 - 428 ↩︎

  2. See letter from George Washington to Battaile Muse, 18 September 1785↩︎

  3. See for example, Military Powers of Attorney (and ↩︎

  4. Marshall CJ’s judgment in Hunt v Rousmanier’s Administrators (US Supreme Court, 1823) is the classic US statement: a naked power is revocable and ends on the principal’s death, but a power coupled with an interest in the thing itself survives and cannot be revoked. The English line (Smart v Sandars, 1848; Frith v Frith, 1906) reached the same point, later codified for powers given as security in the UK’s Powers of Attorney Act 1971, section 4. In the US it lives on in the Restatement (Third) of Agency, section 3.12, “power given as security”, and in the state statutes that say a POA coupled with an interest is not governed by the general rules ↩︎

  5. Disposal of interests” is the point at which a power of attorney stops being a convenience and starts moving property. Its significance comes from several directions.

    The agent has no interest; the principal’s property is what moves. Under an ordinary power of attorney, the agent holds authority only. Title to the house, the shares and the bank balance stays with the principal throughout. So when the agent signs a deed or a transfer, the agent is disposing of someone else’s interest, and the law has always treated that as a different order of act from paying bills or collecting rent. That is the contrast with a power coupled with an interest, where the holder has a stake of their own in the property and the power exists to protect it.

    Formalities attach to the authority, not just the act. Because a disposal of land needed a deed, the law required the authority to make it to be given with the same formality. Historically a letter of attorney to deliver seisin, and after that a sealed instrument to authorize a deed. The modern US form is the equal dignities rule, as in California Civil Code section 2309, and the practical consequences in your six states: the power must be in writing, properly executed, often notarized, and in real estate matters recorded with the deed in the county records. A disposal by an agent under a defective power is a defective disposal, which is why title companies scrutinize POA deeds so hard.

    It’s where the risk of abuse concentrates. Nearly every serious financial-abuse case involves disposal: the house sold, the account emptied, assets gifted to the agent or their family. That is why legislation singles out the disposing powers. The Uniform Power of Attorney Act, section 201, requires an express grant before an agent can make gifts, create or change beneficiary designations or survivorship interests, create or amend trusts, or disclaim property. Your wiki calls these the special and hot tasks. The general grant covers management; disposal in these forms needs the principal’s specific words.

    It collides with the principal’s estate plan. A will may leave the house to a daughter; if the agent sells the house while the principal is alive, the gift fails for ademption, and the proceeds pass under the residue. Some states soften this for sales by conservators or agents, for example Uniform Probate Code section 2-606, but the rules differ, and a disposal by an agent can quietly rewrite who inherits what. This is a reason careful drafters restrict disposal powers or direct how proceeds are to be held.

    It is the hinge of durability. Before durable powers, the authority to dispose ended at exactly the moment it was most needed, when the principal lost capacity and the house had to be sold to fund care. The durable power of attorney exists largely so that disposals can be made on behalf of someone who can no longer make them. That also means disposals under a durable power are made for a person who cannot supervise them, which brings the fiduciary duties and the record-keeping obligations into play.

    And it’s where the two meanings of “power” get confused. Powers of appointment are also powers to dispose of interests, but of property held under a trust or settlement for the benefit of objects chosen by the donee, with roots in the doctrine of uses. A power of attorney disposes of the principal’s own property, for the principal. Keeping that distinction explicit is what stops a technical history of powers of attorney drifting into the law of settlements. ↩︎

  6. Act of Apr. 5, 1954, ch. 486, 1954 Va. Acts 581-82 (“Whenever any power of attorney . . . shall contain . . . words showing the intent of the principal that such power or authority shall not terminate upon his disability, then all power and authority . . . shall continue . . . notwithstanding any subsequent disability.”). ↩︎